h a l f b a k e r yNot so much a thought experiment as a single neuron misfire.
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
Buses are a good way to reduce traffic congestion. Dedicated bus lanes make them a lot faster than driving in rush hour. But what about places where there isn't room for a bus lane? In the UK, the problem is often down to roads passing through the suburbs with just one lane in each direction. Jams occur
daily in the same places.
A monorail would be a solution, but it needs the construction of a whole network in order to be effective. For 95% of the city, a bus works very well; they only suffer when there's no way to avoid these bottlenecks.
Time for a vertically separated bus lane. The bus is modified to be able to run on a monorail as well as on the road. Monorail sections are then only required to get through (or more accurately, over) congested areas, drastically reducing the infrastructure requirement - no stations, or parking, and perhaps a total of five miles of track for the whole city instead of a hundred miles.
On- and off-ramps are located down side streets so as not to interfere with the flow of traffic. The monorail structures themselves could also carry street lights, or perhaps rainwater catchers and hanging baskets.
Guided Bus
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guided_bus
[bs0u0155, Jan 21 2015]
Wuppertal
http://www.urbanrai...hwinkel_2009-12.JPG
Like this in Wuppertal? [xenzag, Jan 22 2015]
Please log in.
If you're not logged in,
you can see what this page
looks like, but you will
not be able to add anything.
Annotation:
|
| |
A. Vertical can also be down as in subway s. |
|
| |
B. ONE WAY in in the morning And ONE WAY out at night ? OR does the traffic clog in both directions. |
|
| |
Was looking at the Naha 'monorail' about two months ago and it quite clearly has two rails. |
|
| |
popbottle,
B - depends on the extent of the traffic problem. In my experience, the traffic will jam at different places on the way in (morning) and out (evening) - so a monorail segment is likely to be useful in one direction only, most of the time. I suppose a system of traffic lights could allow bi-directional use by ensuring that buses only enter when they have a clear path to the exit. |
|
| |
Wouldn't it be better to use a suspended monorail
system? That way there doesn't need to be
dedicated road area for connecting the bus to the
rail. For example, a bidirectional section could
load and unload in a center turn lane that could
still be used for other traffic when a bus wasn't
taking off or landing. A single direction route
could take off from anywhere on the road as long
as there is more than one lane each direction
since tall vehicles might not be able to go under
the monorail track at its lowest point. |
|
| |
The other advantage is that you don't have to
figure out how to put a monorail suspension and
normal wheels on the bottom of the bus. |
|
| |
I did initially consider a suspended system, and I think it's a viable option, but prefer the idea of running the bus over the rail for the following reasons: |
|
| |
- Buses are body-on-frame construction, so the strength is all below the cabin
- Double deckers could be accommodated if the rail was beneath the vehicle |
|
| |
What did you have in mind for modifying a bus so it
could run on a monorail? It seems to me like it
would require a rather major transformation. (extra
wheels in the middle plus wheels that extend down
to hold the sides of the guideway) Or do you just
have a slot down the middle of the bus, requiring
bus passengers to climb a lot of stairs to get up into
the bus from a ground level bus stop? |
|
| |
Reasonable questions all (well, er, possibly excepting the last one - feel free to play the Thunderbirds theme if you wish...). Maybe the minimum-change solution would be a guideway rather than a monorail - one trough for the nearside wheels, one for the offside, narrow on the straights to minimise visual intrusion, broader on the turns to accommodate the differing wheel paths of front and rear wheels. |
|
| |
but guided bus ways are WKTE <link> |
|
| |
Absolutely, as are monorails. The idea here is not the guideway itself, but rather to take a conventional bus, with minimal modification, and to introduce a simple and relatively low cost way to make it immune to traffic jams. |
|
| |
But, no such thing....they all have two rails. |
|
| |
I'm sure that one train on top of the rail and one hanging from the bottom could do synchronised rail-clamp releasing, like running a finger across a piano keyboard, so they could pass. |
|
| |
Possibly to the Thunderbirds theme tune. |
|
| |
In my experience (which includes eight years
driving them), buses are a good way to create
traffic congestion. Quite apart from the fact that,
as with all public transport, they're only useful if
they go from where you are to where you want to
be at the time that you want to go there, they
still travel even when they're empty, taking up
road space to no purpose. Bus lanes only make
things worse, taking a whole (wide) lane-width
out of use for other traffic, even when there's not
a bus around for miles. |
|
| |
To reduce traffic congestion, buses should be
removed from the roads altogether, and this looks
like a fine way to do that, because rather than
making buses immune to traffic jams it makes
traffic immune to bus jams. |
|
| |
Incidentally: "Buses are body-on-frame
construction, so the strength is all below the
cabin". Not necessarily; the Leyland National was
of unitary construction, and was built from the
roof downwards. |
|
| |
In which case, I sit corrected. I'd stand corrected, but there aren't many people on the bus and it seems unnecessary. |
|
| |
Very few buses in Amsterdam - mostly bicycles and trams, and very few cars. Result? - A perfect city for living in that is NOT organised around the geedy, needy, global warming, private car owner. |
|
| |
We were in Amsterdam recently and I remember seeing some very worried-looking people trying to navigate the city in a big 4x4 - very funny. |
|
| |