h a l f b a k e r yIs it soup yet?
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
I recently read a pretty harrowing story set at the collapse of civilization. In it a woman dies after 2 weeks of obstructed labor. Once, this sort of thing was not uncommon. The problem is that the baby is way in there, and slippery, and it is hard to get a grip on the baby's head to help pull it
out. The obstetric forceps was invented to aid delivery in the case of obstructed labor. Suppose you were trying to help a woman with obstructed labor after the collapse of civilization or in the 1500s and had no forceps or other medical facilities of any sort. How could you help her?
I was impressed about the story of the chinese giant Bao who was summoned to help retrieve a foreign object from the stomach of a sick river dolphin. They called him because he had long arms. I wonder, if one if a 5 or 6 year old with small hands could replicate the forceps, reaching in to grab the head and ease the baby out.
Thinking about how this might be faciliated, the child midwife could have clean (clean!) strips of rawhide tied around the fingers, to improve grip on a slipperly baby head.
Forceps history
http://www.med.yale.../obgyntemplate.html
[bungston, Apr 02 2010]
Diary of an interesting year.
http://www.newyorke...1fi_fiction_simpson
This is a gripping and truly harrowing tale. I am still thinking and worrying about it. Do not read it if such things might haunt you. Contains biting. [bungston, Apr 02 2010]
Bao the Chinese giant saves river dolphins with his long arms
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/6178659.stm
You can't beat an arm and a hand for this sort of work. [bungston, Apr 02 2010]
Lost art
http://www.jpgmonli...ge=8;aulast=Chauhan
[mouseposture, Apr 03 2010]
Veterinary Gloves
http://www.qcsupply...ble+Gloves+(JorVet)
As you might imagine, these are quite long for obstetrically examining large mammals. [jurist, Apr 03 2010]
Humboldt Squid
http://en.wikipedia...wiki/Humboldt_squid
Not notably altruistic. [8th of 7, Apr 03 2010]
[link]
|
| |
This is an extremely odd idea. I'm not saying it's not good or
wise or humane, just extremely odd. Odd, odd, oddington
odd, with odd-sauce and a side-order of Odd with extra Odd.
Odd. |
|
| |
That's not to mention how odd the idea is. |
|
| |
Might have saved Tristam Shandy's nose. Not so odd, in
those days. |
|
| |
There used to be something called "version gloves," which
were surgical gloves that went up to the elbow, for reaching
into the uterus and rearranging the baby. I don't think
they're available any more; hard to find an Ob/Gyn who
knows how to do an internal version, even in poorer parts of
the world <link>. |
|
| |
[mouseposture], I'm not familiar with "version gloves", but veterinary doctors frequently use a long latex or poly glove (up to 90 cm/35+ inches) for obstetric examinations. Perhaps that is what you are thinking of, although it doesn't do anything to diminish the size of the vet's hands. <link> |
|
| |
[jurist] Yup, that's the item I had in mind. My point
(inasmuch as I had one, apart from feeling smug about
dredging up a bit of obscure terminology) was that, even in
humans 1) getting a hand in there really is useful, sometimes
and 2) usefulness is in inverse proportion to availability of
more modern techniques. So, agreeing with [bungston],
essentially: I think in a pre-industrial setting, the idea
makes good sense. |
|
| |
raccoons or, for the more natural underwater birthing, octupi. |
|
| |
Might or might not work for the mother-to-be. I dread to think what it might do to the child-midwife. |
|
| |
But not Humboldt squid. They're carnivorous. |
|
| |
Why the distinction, [1/8/7]? Don't octupi also eat crabs, snails, mollusks, fish and other octopi? |
|
| |
Humboldt squid are notably aggressive, and have been known to attack divers. |
|
| |
Octupi, other squid and particularly cuttlefish are curious and inquisitive but tend to flee rather than attack creatures many times their size. They will tolerate humans nearby; Humbolts won't. |
|
| |
Most of the cephalopods are quite intelligent and display reasoning ability. It should not be impossible to train them to perform medical tasks. With the growing popularity of "water births" an appropriate aquatic operating environment is already available. |
|
| |
Indeed - the first and most vital part of any doctor's training should be to learn how to mimic a small edible flatfish at a moment's notice; who knows where and when the necessity will arise ? |
|
| |
Not the first by any means. Best to start with sessile
molluscs, and work up gradually to teleosts. (Learning to be
inconspicous, in the presence of predators, actually *is* an
early, vital part of a doctor's training.) |
|
| |
Yes, we said that already. |
|
| |