h a l f b a k e r yIs it soup yet?
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
Standing water on the road surface, be that liquid or snow, reduces friction between tires and the road. That friction is required in order to accelerate, stop or turn. Tires have a tread pattern of various grooves or "sipes" that are designed to give the water somewhere to go. Tires designed to cope
with more water have more and larger sipes. Consequently, this leads to less tire in contact with the road in dry conditions and the smaller blocks of tread tend to flex, leading to local heating/inefficiency as well as a perceivable change in driving feel.
Inevitably, everyday tires end up as something of a compromise* and when the road gets really wet, the amount of standing water can overwhelm the capacity of the sipes leading to a layer of water between the whole tire contact patch and the road surface. This is known as aquaplaning/hydroplaning, depending on your latin/greek preferences, presumably**. This is sometimes fun/occasionally terrifying depending on variable conditions.
To prevent this, we need to ensure that the amount of water on the road surface is below the capacity of the sipes. Specifically, reduce the amount of water to that below the volume the sipes can remove PER UNIT TIME. The easiest way to do this is to slow down, move slow enough and cars tend to sink through the water layer and gain contact with the road surface***. However, since slowing down is time-consuming and suffers from poor buy-in from the general public, we need another option.
I propose a nozzle in front of each tire to direct high-pressure air in an Air-Knife<link> format to clear a significant amount of water from the road surface immediately in front of the tire contact patch. This would act a bit like those super-noisy hand dryers we've all tried, as an efficient way of separating water from a sold object. Only we replace our hands with some road. The exact shape of the jet will require experimentation, I'd start with a forward-facing arrow shape or possibly an inward facing angle to drive water under the car to minimize additional road spray.
A brief experiment with a tray of water in the work bathroom (over the weekend) reveals that a Dyson Airblade is eminently capable of removing a half-inch of water and spraying it all over the wall/floor/me.
The amount of air required isn't huge, requiring in the region of a few hundred Watts of fan/compressor power. The closer the nozzle is to the surface, the more efficient, but again, experimentation required to find a good compromise. The total downward thrust will be negligible at a few kG at most. Sadly, I can't find a way to make it legal by Formula 1 rules, I think it contravenes "movable aerodynamic device".
*get winter tires people, they improve going, turning and stopping. AWD only does the first one.
**This is all, of course, pending the archaeological discovery of a mosaic depicting an out-of-control chariot in slightly too much standing water. Although chariot wheels have favorable profiles in terms of aspect ratio etc. for the prevention of aqua/hydro planing. Perhaps derived from hard-won chariot experience?
***Prudent to check you're in a car and not a boat at this point.
Air Knife
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_knife [bs0u0155, Jan 02 2024]
Air-Blade Tire Water Removal
//WHY not use the air stream to blast the water off the road in front of the tyre pocmloc, Dec 27 2023// [pocmloc, Jan 03 2024]
Hovercraft and other air-cushion vehicles
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hovercraft [bs0u0155, Jan 05 2024]
Air Knife Tread Cleaner
Air_20Knife_20Tread_20Cleaner //An extension of the idea would be to focus a high- pressure air jet right in front of the tire// bs0u0155 Feb 13 2020 [bs0u0155, Jan 08 2024]
[link]
|
|
Isnt a moving vehicle which blows air downwards a hovercraft? (Yes, I know a hovercraft is different but this might have a slightly hovercrafty effect) |
|
|
This is genius. A great thing to try, and brilliant if it works. |
|
|
I would think sideways. Also, to get back on topic, I would think that the jet should blow sideways to sweep the water off to the side of the tyre track. |
|
|
Also <link> if I hadn't been away drinking too much the past few days I would have considered writing this up and beating [bs0u0155] to claim the £10 million reward for the first air-blade road clearing idea of 2024. Ah well back to thinking sideways and looking forward to plain lentils for dinner again. |
|
|
According to the wikipedia page, air knives blow air through holes or slits to create a laminar flow.
It occurs to me that you do need a decent clearance between the road and the fan - but, you know quite well what that separation will be. So really you want to clear away water at a specific distance from the source. |
|
|
Now, some of you are probably way ahead of me here, but I'd like to consider the concept of the shaped charge. This is an explosive, formed into a specific shape against a metal 'liner', used for demolition and anti-armour missiles. The shape of the cavity focusses the force of the projected liner against a single point. For demolition work, linear strips are made to 'precisely' cut metal or concrete. |
|
|
So, by analogy with that, it seems to me it might be possible to focus the force of the fan more effectively by careful design of the vent(s), conceptually bringing several slower-moving jets of air together just above the road surface.
On whether this would work at speed my mental model is even more vague. |
|
|
//Isnt a moving vehicle which blows air downwards a hovercraft?// |
|
|
I think you have to blow enough air downwards that you hover. A moving vehicle that blows air downwards but doesn't hover is just a "craft". I always thought that the history of the hovercraft was fairly simple: British genius Christopher Cockerell has a great idea, shortly afterwards we have cross-channel commercial hovercraft. It's more complex, however. <link> |
|
|
//£10 million reward for the first air-blade road clearing idea of 2024.// |
|
|
Is the cheque/check in the mail? |
|
|
I hope so! If you don't get it in the next few days, you should go to the post office and complain. |
|
|
This is genius. A great thing to try, and brilliant if it works.
Loris, Jan 03 2024 |
|
|
My candidate would have been
//slowing down is time-consuming and suffers from poor buy-in from the general public//
or
//Sadly, I can't find a way to make it legal//
or
//Perhaps derived from hard-won chariot experience?// |
|
| |