h a l f b a k e r yThunk.
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
We hear diffent types of music and it triggers certain types of
feelings. I tell people that here's
all you need to know about song writing. (besides needing to
be talented to do it) Major cords are
happy and positive, minor chords are sad or spooky, they're
colors in your pallet to paint a
picture.
But why? Is this intrinsic or are we just conditioned to react
that
way when we hear certain chords? First order of business
might
be to explore music of
different cultures and see what they consider happy or sad,
but from what I see, there seems to be a pretty universal
human response to sad, happy or scary music.
Have the test subjects watch only entertainment for a year
with flipped soundtracks. As the chainsaw wielding psycho
bursts into the room play the Benny Hill theme and in the
cartoon where the happy bunny wins the race against the
mean old tortoise play the theme from Friday the 13th.
Then, after several months of Clockwork Orange style
association manipulation
ask them what kind of moods these swapped styles invoke
when they hear them.
Any volunteers?
This:
https://www.123rf.c...-with-his-hand.html [doctorremulac3, Nov 21 2021]
associated with this soundtrack.
https://www.youtube...watch?v=wP8_mhRkkfc [doctorremulac3, Nov 21 2021]
While this:
https://www.bigbadt...ationDetails/153386 [doctorremulac3, Nov 21 2021]
associated with this.
https://youtu.be/MK6TXMsvgQg [doctorremulac3, Nov 21 2021]
Inspired by this.
The_20Day_20the_20Music_20Turned [doctorremulac3, Nov 21 2021]
Iain Morley, The Prehistory of Music
https://global.oup....7269?cc=gb&lang=en& Explains in overwhelmingly technical detail how music developed within Human evolution, and basically concludes that it is closely related to emotional expression and vocalisation and gesture in animals in general [pocmloc, Nov 21 2021]
Go to 2:05
https://www.youtube...watch?v=OxAjXtJf5AE This is fascinating, I'm digging it then they change the beat, much faster and the chimp seems to stop rocking about just like I did. Then they settle into a groove and he gets back into it. [doctorremulac3, Nov 21 2021]
Interesting, but doesn't address the major vs minor chord thing.
https://www.youtube...watch?v=5NfLKoq9PeA [doctorremulac3, Nov 21 2021]
<shrugs> you tell me
https://www.reddit....ore_his_rallies_to/ [2 fries shy of a happy meal, Nov 22 2021]
Iain Morley online lecture
http://podcasts.ox....pening-presentation Hope this stands in as an audiobook substitute. [pocmloc, Nov 22 2021]
[link]
|
|
That's getting very deep into "nature vs. nurture" territory. But
a very interesting idea, nonetheless. |
|
|
Yes music is very low level emotional signalling. See Iain Morley's book <link> |
|
|
Well here's one thing we know for sure, bobbing to rhythms is
something that's not just a human thing. |
|
|
Wonder if there's an audio of that book. I don't read but it
looks like an interesting subject. |
|
|
You may find this interesting. There are certain notes which even at barely audible levels produce unease or discomfort in humans across the board so I imagine the same holds true in reverse. Apparently Hitlers boys knew this and would broadcast these negative sounds prior to his appearance in front of crowds so that when the noise ceased his arrival coincided with feelings of mass relief and well being. |
|
|
...and then there's the brown note. |
|
|
//would broadcast these negative sounds prior to his
appearance in front of crowds so that when the noise ceased
his arrival coincided with feelings of mass relief and well
being.// |
|
|
So like when a Nirvana song ends? |
|
|
...or Nickleback. Exactly! |
|
|
Might be true, but sounds to me like an urban myth. |
|
|
Let me look, it's Sunday, I'm taking a day off <gasp> true story. |
|
|
Okay. <shrugs> Here's Reddit historian's take on it. [link] I just know it was something I read on here years ago. |
|
|
I was going to suggest you just write to Morley and ask, but I found out that he died earlier this year at the age of 46. But I found a lecture that he did shortly before his book came out <link> |
|
|
Cool, thanks poc. I'll check it out. |
|
|
As a musician, it's an intriguing idea, but I'm not sure it'd do much more than confirm that people can be conditioned. I don't see it having much bearing on the emotions we associate with music when _not_ conditioned in unusual ways. |
|
|
I guess as a former musician myself (still get royalty
checks so I guess I'm still a musician) I wonder why I
feel one thing with one chord and another with a
different one. Minor chords are sad or spooky, major
are happy. |
|
|
And jazz chords are on cocaine. |
|
|
No. Instead, I suggest community radio station, where participants can
push updates to playlist, and vote for what's next, that helps set
community mood, and participants can tune-in as they desire. |
|
|
Regarding the 1-year experiment - I'm sure it's being done by certain
media corporations. |
|
| |