h a l f b a k e r yNot so much a thought experiment as a single neuron misfire.
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
Please log in.
Before you can vote, you need to register.
Please log in or create an account.
|
I am constantly waving at people (which may or may not
see me) to indicate "your turn, go ahead".
So, Instead of a passive receive only method of turn
signals (current method). It would be nice to have a two
dialog show clear intent that you allow the other car to go.
For instance, consider
you and two other cars converge at
a four way stop, other cars ahead and to left. It become
unclear as to who is go next and who is willing to wait.
Usually with two cars lurching forward at the same time
then everyone waving at each other signalling intent for to
other car to go first.
If there were 3 lights on the front of each car, probably
green (one center, one near each side similar to turn
signals). These could indicate that you want the other cars
to go. You would choose which lights to display. So in the
prior example you could set Left and Ahead on, indicating
that the other two cars should go and you will wait.
Of course these would be optional and only used when
needed (less frequently then turn signals too). But could
help for the socially awkward situations and prevent two
people from pulling out at the same time.
The negative I could see is when two people turn on their
go ahead signals at the same time. This system will only
work if people have different levels of politeness.
[link]
|
| |
I've always wanted a "going straight" arrow on my hood. So when I'm approaching an intersection I can signal "going straight" so that nobody thinks I'm turning and goes right in front of me. |
|
| |
Seriously though, I think some type of car-to-car communication other than turn signals would greatly cut down on accidents. |
|
| |
Well, the signal for "not turning" is and always has been "not signalling at all". There's a hand signal for it though, which most drivers, in my experience, utterly fail to comprehend. |
|
| |
Yes, I would like a signal to emphasize the point. For instance, if I plan on going at a 4 way stop, I want to tell someone else "yes I am going now!" |
|
| |
No offense, but if you are // constantly waving at people
... to indicate "your turn, go ahead"//, it may be because
you have the right of way and they're waiting for you. Here
in Maine, where most people are pretty friendly and
typically not in a hurry, 4-way stops can become very
polite battlegrounds in the war between good-naturedness
and traffic regulations. |
|
| |
Same here, but for some reason 'first come, first go' is too
complicated for some drivers. |
|
| |
heheh, that just happened to me: myself and another driver were approaching a 4way; both of us slowed to a stop reeeeaaallly slowly to give the other the "first come first serve" token. The green light's a good idea [+], a red light might get confused between being a command for the other driver to stop or an indication that the vehicle's stopping. |
|
| |
But if you have an 'after you' light then someone will come up with a 'no I insist, after you' light, and the next thing you know we're all driving around in a Monty Pythonesque ministry of silly stops sketch. |
|
| |
// the next thing you know we're all driving around in a Monty Pythonesque ministry of silly stops sketch// |
|
| |
If you could link that in with |
|
| |
1) A Macgregor tartan light that means "yes, I actually am indicating a right turn and I'm turning right, it's not that I just forget to turn it off after the last turn" |
|
| |
2) An alternating yellow/green light for "I'm not sure if I'm turning or not, it looks like the right corner, but the last time I went this way was at night..so I could be wrong". |
|
| |
//At a 4 way stop, the first to arrive goes first// |
|
| |
When I first mentioned 4 way stops to an Aussie neighbour who was a driving instructor he looked at me blankly and asked: "what's a 4-way stop?" When I then explained that whoever got there first went first and all the rest of the rules it sounded pretty chaotic even to my ears. But it works. |
|
| |
No, what's chaotic is a _one-way_ stop, all-too-often found
in my neck of the woods. That's a four-way intersection
with only one stop sign; drivers coming from the other
three directions can breeze right through. Why? I have no
fu€#!ng clue. |
|
| |
Traffic circles are the way to go. Once we learned how to
use the 3- and 4-lane roundabouts we encountered in
England, we were stunned at how efficiently they moved
heavy traffic through intersections. Even the ones with
stoplights cycled much faster than signal intersections here
in the States. We felt much more secure as motorcyclists,
since everyone was going the same direction and each lane
of traffic shifted at the same time. We weren't constantly
looking out for 'Left-Turn Larry' (I guess in the UK that
would be 'Right-Turn Ronnie') . |
|
| |
This makes me think that maybe all cars should be equipted with *traffic lights* of their own! |
|
| |
//Traffic circles are the way to go// |
|
| |
Call them roundabouts. No, really. It's just much
more fun than calling them "traffic circles". You've
already called your major roads "freeways", which is
much more positive than our "motorways". So,
embrace "roundabout". |
|
| |
[21], you said "Here in Washington State, the first person to the intersection has right of way. At a 4 way stop, the first to arrive goes first, then the rest go in clockwise order. " |
|
| |
So how do you deal with a situation where two drivers arrive at exactly the same time? Here in CA, the driver on the right has the right of way. |
|
| |
This fails to address instances where all four drivers arrive simultaneously. In that case, usually the two most clearheaded and assertive drivers going opposite directions go first, then the other two drivers go "Oh, that looks clever" and they follow suit. |
|
| |
I had somebody in a car with deeply tinted windows waving me on the other day. They may have been indicating that I could go first, or they could have been making obscene and threatening gestures - I couldn't tell which. A light such as referenced in this idea would have been useful (+). |
|
| |
// Call them roundabouts // |
|
| |
I'd love to, as that's the term I prefer and clearly the more
fun to say and hear. Sadly, many of my countrymen are not
so worldly, and amongst those who even know what they
are (a minority, I think) the term 'traffic circle' has taken
hold. If only the concept would as well, but there are
many who don't understand their function and others who
proclaim that the cost and inconvenience of reconfiguring
major intersections outweighs the benefit. They are, of
course, bloody fucking WRONG, because once the thing's
built the cost and inconvenience is over with, yet the
benefit lasts until anti-gravity technology comes to every
driveway and garage. But, we're Americans and
subsequently have very short attention spans. |
|
| |
My hometown, which is actually a small city and is
blessedly in another part of the state, replaced a
cumbersome 3-way intersection with a single-lane
roundabout a decade or so ago, saying that it was a 'trial'
and more would come if it worked well. Predictably, it
works very well, yet no more roundabouts--sorry, that's
traffic circles--have appeared. |
|
| |
I live in a fiefdom where stop signs mean 'stop if another
car is visible' and traffic signals are a magical wonder
found only in far-away lands, so thankfully I don't really
have to worry about this shit. |
|
| |
"the benefit lasts until anti-gravity technology comes to every driveway and garage" |
|
| |
I noticed that, in Italy, the right-of-way went to the
driver first to cover his/her eyes with a forearm and
accelerate violently through the intersection. It
seemed to work remarkably well. |
|
| |
// You never heard of tarmac? // |
|
| |
Oh, I've heard of it. Even saw me a picture, once. |
|
| |
This would work good when telling pedestrians to go as well. I walk a lot and I often let a car pass before I cross the road (or else they just go on their own...). I don't tend to look at the driver (or if I do it isn't always easy to see them), so I don't know their intentions. This would make me feel a bit safer when crossing the road. |
|
| |