h a l f b a k e r yMy hatstand runneth over
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
Please log in.
Before you can vote, you need to register.
Please log in or create an account.
|
As far as I am aware, the music and CD industry loose billions of US dollars to fake manufacturers.
I would propose that on each and every CD player, the manufactures install (cost split 50/50 manufacturer and CD music owners), a tiny chip on every single licensed CD. Once placed inside the CD player,
a laser-lecture ID decoder would identify the source, serial numbers and so on of the legal CD that has been inserted.
If an illegal CD is placed, automatically the decoder would send a signal to the main board of the CD player, which will in turn activate a switch rendering the machine inoperative, and at the same time, activating a laser beam potent enough to destroy the fake CD.
Microchips are so small now a days, that they can easily be placed on the surface of any CD, without posing a harm to the CD itself, nor to the CD player. In the interim, billions of dollaras can be saved, and I am sure, at a fraction of the cost...........unless of course, I am totally out on technology cost estimates.
Bunt (not related to this idea)
http://www.halfbakery.com/idea/Bunt
The second runner up for stupid idea of the week is... [Cedar Park, Oct 17 2004]
Horse-Be-Clean (also not related)
http://www.halfbake...idea/Horse-be-clean
The first runner up is... [Cedar Park, Oct 17 2004]
Super Matter / Anti-Matter Prop. (ditto)
http://www.halfbake...ti-matter_20prop_2e
And the winner is... [Cedar Park, Oct 17 2004]
How to burn a CD
http://www.prairien...ell/cd_burning.html
Lots of un. But don't do it when your wife/mother's around. [DrCurry, Oct 17 2004]
Sony Introduces Self-Destructing DVD Player
http://bbspot.com/N.../self_destruct.html
Here's another way to deal with piracy. [krelnik, Oct 17 2004]
Load this up with CD's
http://www.dansande...es/discgun/gun2.jpg
I've got 1000 hours free, I've got your 1000 hours free right here... [latka, Oct 17 2004]
... Or Super-size this bad puppy
http://www.firebox....409&showAllImages=1
Judging by the picture, mini-cd's might fit in this [latka, Oct 17 2004]
AOL CD Launcher
http://www.halfbake...AOL_20CD_20Launcher
idea related to some of the discussion, by [Half-baked D@nish] [krelnik, Oct 17 2004]
[link]
|
| |
Seriously stupid idea of the week. No, wait, we've had four of those already and it's only Wednesday. |
|
| |
hmmn I think they should make legit CDs at a price that's reasonable and people can afford instead |
|
| |
Not to mention legit CD-R's. |
|
| |
I'd rather have a REAL fake-CD blaster - if it's not a redbook-standard CD and one of those horrible "protected" things that can't play in all CD players or your computer, it's gone. |
|
| |
The funny thing about protected CDs that I've never really understood is how they're supposed to prevent pirating. Sure, it's not possible to rip it directly from disc on one's computer. But what is to stop someone from taking a high quality line-out from their stereo, ripping it to wav, then converting to mp3? |
|
| |
Good point [rapid]. But the "protected CDs" only work via software protection. The information read by the laser, is not in the expected format for translating by the codecs.
You can easily get around this by creating a codec that handles the data in a different way, similarly to DVD players. |
|
| |
//I've never really understood is how they're supposed to prevent pirating// |
|
| |
They figure that the CDs are essentially unplayable, and therefore impossible to copy - or listen to. |
|
| |
I've heard of people who go to listening stations and copy the album through the headphones, though I imagine nowadays nobody bothers with that anymore. I know it's also possible to disable the copy protection with a marker pen... |
|
| |
I heard recently (not sure if it was a reliable source) that recording companies have made more money the past few years since burning became popular. |
|
| |
Sony is apparently thinking along these same lines, see my first link. |
|
| |
Hm...note that that site also has headlines like "Linux Developer Gets Laid." But looking at the dateline, I wonder if they got that idea from here...? |
|
| |
I have only visited this site for 3 days, and I can say this is the dumbest idea I will ever read on this site. Who wants to buy a product that will destroy one's possessions. Another person could put the product burned CD into the player without the owner's knowledge, thereby rendering their machine ineffective. Plus, if anyone is so goody-goody for lack of a better word, to buy this crap, they probably aren't exactly major players in the pirating business. No on e used to complain when we dubbed tapes and recorded movies off tv. Now that the music and movies are on disks, it is apparently a tragedy. Puff daddy is already rich. Hell, charge more taxes and pay teachers more. dont' give money to all these whiny artists so they can bling bling up and down the street. I love rap music, the cuplrits of money blowing and even pirate combating, but I will burn their cd in a heartbeat. If I burn 10 for every one I buy, I am getting my money's worth. Barely. |
|
| |
3 days <snigger> have a pole (or a poll even) for your pants |
|
| |
you are quite right though <g> |
|
| |
I dunno, brutus, have you read the goat piss one yet? |
|
| |
As somebody who works in the music biz and is trying to make a living from it I can understand what 7 up is getting at with this idea but it is not going to work for all the reasons that other people have pointed out. I have a CD player hooked up to a 16 track mixer with a stereo line input straight into my sorry looking old mac. I can record straight into aiff, convert into mpeg3 and send as email to anywhere in the world.
The 5 major labels and there are are only 5( EMI, BMG, Vivendi, Sony and TimeWarner-aol )have got to learn to adapt which they are starting to do. Vivendi, one of the major 5 labels own MTV, VH1 and also MP3.com.
BMG and EMI are starting to buy publishing companies because they know that that is where the money is in the long run. Sony have such wide varity of products they can make money from hardware, publishing back cataloge, computer games ect.
Burning CDs or downloading mp3s isn't killing music. I actively encourage it. Its a great marketing tool if used right.
I'm a big fan of The Sopranos. I taped every show but I still went out and brought the box sets when they came out. |
|
| |
I was hoping this was some sort of gun that would take AOL coasters as ammo. Like a giant version of the existing toy guns I remember as a wee one, it would shoot these little [US] dime sized disc spinning off the front of it. |
|
| |
//gun that would take AOL coasters as ammo//
We did that idea, [latka], see my second link. |
|
| |
How would the cd player know what was illegal? What if I burned a backup copy of a bought cd, then the bought got destroyed, allowing me to use the backup? What if I made my own music? What if I made a compilation of songs from my cd's that I own (which is allowed)? What if I did this at a friends house or somewhere untrackable by the cd player? |
|
| |
The fundemental problem, is that there is no way to stop people from copying information (this information must be readable by older CD players I.E must adhere strictly to Redbook or Orangebook specifications) and anything that can be read by this 'lowest common demominator' of CD players can, naturally, be read by any computer program willing to disregard a few errant errors, and if I understand correctly, just about anyone involved in 'ripping' CDs to the computer has a tool more then capable of this. And need I point out, even if they don't, Sonic Foundry, which came with my MiniDisc Player, did a beautiful job last time tried it ~_^. |
|
| |