h a l f b a k e r yBuy 1/4, get 1/4 free.
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
Please log in.
Before you can vote, you need to register.
Please log in or create an account.
|
The internal combustion engine requires a
cooling
system.
There are several ways to accomplish this but
most common road
vehicles use a closed loop of circulating liquid
coolant composed
largely of water. Typically, a mechanical
centrifugal pump forces
water through channels in the
cylinder head and
block where it is
heated by waste heat from combustion. The
water then exits the
engine and is passed through a "radiator" * to
cool down,
completing the circuit.
The point of all this is to stabilize the temperature
of the engine
under varied conditions, preventing problems
with thermal
stresses on materials and to optimize
combustion. The
temperature selected depends upon the role and
construction of
the engine but is typically between 75-120 C.
Over the years a refinements have been included.
A "thermostat"
acts as a valve to short circuit the cooling system
when the engine
is below optimal temperature, decreasing the
warm-up time.
Clutch equipped mechanical water pumps and
radiator fans
remove the direct relationship between engine
speed and cooling
capacity and later, electric fans and pumps
enabled finer control.
Similarly "water" cooled engines now circulate
various coolant
blends containing water laced with corrosion
inhibitors, pH
stabilizers, anti foaming agents and substances
to depress the
freezing point.
Water is a great choice for moving heat around, it
has a high
specific heat capacity, 4.2 J/g/K reasonable
density and is liquid
at pleasing temperatures. During warm up
however, these
qualities play against water. It's often the case
that a cold start
can lead to an engine circulating water at -20C
which actively
slows the progress toward ideal operating
temperature. To reduce
this, strategies include restricting flow rate,
reducing coolant
volume or possibly reducing the specific heat
capacity of the
coolant. However, this must be balanced by
having enough
thermal capacity to cool the engine at maximum
load.
It is possible to improve both aspects, we can
use the tremendous
energy changes observed during solid-liquid
phase change in
eutectic substances. Water absorbs 4.2 J/g/K,
but phase changing
sodium acetate trihydrate absorbs 289 J/g at its
melting point of
58C**. Now, liquids and solids are usually
handled very
differently, a traditional water pump would not
function too well
trying to circulate solidified sodium acetate.
So, lets encase our eutectic material in polymer
(e.g. PTFE)
spheres and make the coolant a suspension. The
spheres should be
about 20-30um in diameter, a wall thickness of 1-
2um seems
feasible, and PTFE can be adapted to be a little
better at thermal
conductivity. The density of the liquid and the
spheres should be
roughly equal so that the suspension is nice and
stable.
Say the suspension is 5% spheres in what is
essentially water. The
specific heat capacity is down to ~4, 5% less than
water, right up
to the melting point where it suddenly jumps
350%. Now, sodium
acetate trihydrate is a known example used in
some hand-heating
packs, sodium acetate is also good but has a
melting temp too
high. I looked at some potassium, magnesium
and calcium acetate
derivatives and saw figures of 350, 80 and 160C,
which suggests
there should be a Na/K/Be/Mg/Ca
acetate/propionate +/- hydrate
variant that has an appropriate melting
temperature.
So, if you have 2-3.5 thermal capacity, you can
downsize the
liquid part of system, oh and the heater would be
amazing.
* Very little radiating takes place, while obviously
designed for
maximum surface area, most of the elements are
flanked by other
equally hot elements, very little net radiation.
Instead heat is
largely transferred by conduction to the air
flowing through them.
So when your mechanic falsely refers to the
"radiator" be sure to
reprimand them. They will be glad to correct such
a glaring
blemish in their knowledge.
** although a domestic heating system would be
fine with this, it's
just below the pain threshold so the temperature
of radiators
would fall into a less burny range, but their heat
capacity would
increase.. if you can get the transfer working a bit
faster.
PTFE
https://en.wikipedi...tetrafluoroethylene ...for anyone else who doesn't know what that is. [2 fries shy of a happy meal, Apr 22 2017]
Eutectic system
https://en.wikipedi...iki/Eutectic_system ...for anyone else who doesn't know what _that_ is. [bungston, Apr 23 2017]
Heats of Fusion
https://en.wikipedi.../Enthalpy_of_fusion I sort of know what this is, but still have to look up numbers. [bungston, Apr 23 2017]
[link]
|
|
Would 1µm spheres survive? Or would they be squished/crushed at a few points in the engine? |
|
|
But are they going to taste nice in Atlantic Salmon? |
|
|
I found the heat of fusion for water to be 334
j/gram. That is better than what is listed for
sodium acetate and probably comparable for any
of the eutectic acetate salts - certainly cheaper. |
|
|
I take it that this phase change aspect for water is
hard to use because of the difficulty circulating
solids. But you have made a workaround with the
microspheres. Why not put water in the
microspheres? You could circulate the spheres in
some low freezing solution (hydrocarbon, methanol
+ water etc). You get your phase change benefit. |
|
|
Or maybe I misunderstand - maybe this is to get
the phase change benefit at the higher
temperature where engines are hot but should not
get hotter? |
|
|
//Would 1µm spheres survive? Or would they be
squished/crushed at a few points in the engine?// |
|
|
I'm going for much more than that, 20+ Otherwise the
content/containment ratio reduces badly and they
would perform mostly like plain PTFE balls. Anyhow, I
think they'd be fine. The water in an engine isn't like
the oil or fuel, it's not driven by a gear pump, there's no
tremendous pressure changes, no tiny holes. Everything
is on the scale of mm or cm and the flow can be nicely
controlled. We have some fluorescent beads that we
have had stirring in a cuvette for days, they've been
through a flow cytometer 100's of times, they're fine,
and PTFE is tougher. |
|
|
//I wonder if when we are talking about exotic
materials whether the lubricant could also be the
coolant.// |
|
|
It is already, there are a many variants but the oil is
always considered part of the cooling. My motorcycle
manual goes to great lengths to explain that the engine
is "Air/OIL cooled" The oil circulation is used to move
heat around so that the parts are all at similar
temperatures, also, there's an oil cooler, this functions
in the same way as a water "radiator". Turbocharged
cars use an oil circuit to and from the turbocharger
which operates at temperatures that would trouble
water. They often have features such as oil jets pointed
at the underside of the pistons to cool an otherwise
isolated component. |
|
|
//maybe this is to get the phase change benefit at the
higher temperature where engines are hot but should
not get hotter?// |
|
|
Exactly this. Water has excellent enthalpy of
fusion/specific heat capacity properties, but for many
reasons, around 100C has been the operating
temperature of engines for a century. Much hotter and
emissions start to move in undesirable directions
regarding nitrous oxides and the difference between
starting temp and running temp gets larger creating
problems with uneven expansion. Aluminium is pretty
useless as a structural material above 200C as well, and
thats the engine material of choice nowadays. Much
cooler and there are problems with fuel vaporization
and the rate of excess heat rejection becomes very
problematic, imagine if you set your engine to work
well at 65C and left it on a black parking space in full
sunlight in Nevada. Your car would be overheating
before you started it. |
|
|
The whole point is to create a dramatic increase in
energy absorption and rejection moving above and
below the operating temperature. The sphere cores
absorb huge energy while melting in the engine and
reject huge energy while re-solidifying in the radiator. |
|
|
Well, this sounds like an excellent idea. You have my full and unfettered permission to test this out on [8th]'s Ford Anglia. Or, for that matter, on [8th]. |
|
|
I think the collective would be very interested in
such technology. I'm sure they are eager to increase
the cooling capacity of various blood systems to
handle the more interesting and higher powered
"upgrades" |
|
| |