h a l f b a k e r yExpensive, difficult, slightly dangerous, not particularly effective... I'm on a roll.
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
Please log in.
Before you can vote, you need to register.
Please log in or create an account.
|
In every government facility, or large building, train station or airport,
bombing attempts are serious threats. Throwing the bomb (or
suspected bomb, including the suspect?) down some bomb hole isn't
always an option, but encasing it/him is. A large metal shell is not
very portable but a huge
water balloon should do the trick.
This large water balloon would be included wherever fire hoses are, for
convenience of filling up. When a threat is deemed worthy of the
balloon, place the balloon over purported explosive, fill up and you
have a huge water balloon over it, ready to absorb any explosion.
Or it will redirect the bomb's blast into the floor, doing more damage
than expected.
[link]
|
| |
The dam busting bouncing bombs were intended to detonate in close contact with the dam, the water providing resistance to maximise damage to the wall; so yes, it probably would increase damage to the floor. But that's likely to be a better scenario. |
|
| |
hmm.... might be worth researching but my kneejerk reaction is that blowing a few windows out is better than doing structural damage to the floor as well as attendant water damage. |
|
| |
hmm take 2, ya know, flashing a ton or two of water into steam usually isn't that good an idea. |
|
| |
A fun fireworks game: Fill a 2-liter plastic bottle with water and launch bottle-rockets down into it. They go off with a thump, and the bottle jumps and sprays a bit. It's quiet-ish but messy. |
|
| |
Dunno how that's relevant, but it implies that this idea will at least cut down on noise. Otherwise, yeah, it's tamping or whatever that is to direct a blast. It will help in some cases, such as outdoor bombs with only ground underneath. I think it will be a good addition to a bomb-squad's kit, so I'm croissanting. |
|
| |
Bit tangential to the post, but rather than a solid concrete blast container, a double-walled kevlar tube that's semi-disposable... just fill the wall with water. |
|
| |
Is water more effective than, say, sand? |
|
| |
Water outlets are more common than sand outlets. |
|
| |
I thought this was an anti-grenade water balloon intended to slow lightweight projectiles (shrapnel) by being thrown or placed on top of an active grenade. This 3mm-walled anti-grenade water balloon would double as a refillable thermos or giant hip flask. You could then rationalize the abundance of alcohol as a safety precaution. |
|
| |
[FlyingToaster] To heat 1000 kg of water from 20°C to 100°C requires about 335 MJ. To boil it requires a furthur 2,256 MJ. Total 2,591 MJ. This is the energy given off by 392 kg of detonating nitroglycerine. No chemical explosive greatly exceeds nitroglycerine's power, so as long as several times as much water as explosive is used the water won't all be converted to steam. |
|
| |
I think the idea's interesting enough to experiment on, except for the actual "balloon" idea (sorry [twitch]) which would simply cause an incredible amount of damage to the floor. |
|
| |
Nobody here mentioned the Mythbusters episode "guts and grenades" yet? They tested how much jumping on a hand grenade would reduce shrapnel injuries to bystanders. They also tested the effect of dropping the grenade into a bucket of water, which indeed reduced shrapnel damage significantly.
However, the water was thrown around instead of it turning into steam. Most non-Hollywood explosions cause pressure waves (and shrapnel) rather than heat.
I'd imagine the water balloon to be useful if you wanted to reduce damage to the surroundings, or if you need more time for evacuating the area. |
|
| |
What we need is some kind of inexpensive powdered additive which would make the water thixotropic; perhaps a mixture of cornflour, sugar, milk solids, and synthetic vanilla. It could be stored in the balloon until required. The action of filling the balloon from a fire hose should mix the powder into the water sufficiently, |
|
| |
I call it: Containment Utilising Starch Thixotropy Available for Rapid Deployment |
|
| |
Why would tossing guck around be preferable to tossing water around ? |
|
| |
[BunsenHoneydew] We are not worthy. |
|
| |
//thixotropic// sp. dilatant |
|
| |